Oh...
Pretty baby
This feeling I just can't hide
You got me mystified

Oh...
Pretty darling
This feeling is deep inside
You got me mystified

The light that shines around you
It blinds my eyes
There's a magic surrounds you
Tell me where your secret lies

Oh...
Pretty darling
This feeling is deep inside
You got me mystified

Oh...
Pretty baby
This feeling I just can't hide
You got me mystified

You got me mystified
Mystified
Mystified
Mystified

WEBMISTRESS speculates:

As in World Turning, I am not sure who wrote what. If I were to guess, I'd say that Lindsey's contributions were mostly musical. However, I'm certainly not going to preclude the possibility that he wrote some of the lyrics as well. In general it's a song about someone who is fascinated with a person who's hard to figure out, a person's who's almost magic and hides a wealth of secrets. I imagine Lindsey could relate to what he didn't write!

 

DW speculates:

Christine wrote the music and says that Lindsey wrote the words, even though Chris sings it. If ever Lindsey wrote a more traditional, tender love song, this is it. I don't think Stevie was on his mind at all. I think this was for and about Cheri. It was written at a time when he and Cheri were still in a relatively new relationship in 85/maybe 86, and it's about discovering the mysteries of this new love. He doesn't really think he understands her yet, but it's clear that he's enthralled by her and will work hard to find out "where her secret lies." Beautiful song. I love everything about it.