|
|
|
WEBMISTRESS speculates:
This song is not too exciting. In fact, it's a little schmaltzy. And I really don't get the analogy here. Why are they like smiling islands? Are they happy isolated or something? What the heck is a smiling island anyway? But, then again, I turned 25 before I discovered that a Loving Cup is what you get as a trophy (and here I thought Lindsey Buckingham was just being creative on that one! But I digress). At any rate, while this song is nothing to write home about, at least Stevie gets to do more than sing backup on it. But why didn't Robbie write something different for her to sing? By having her repeat, word for word, the FOUR stanzas he had just gotten through singing, it becomes redundant to the point of pain. Just my opinion.
KEVIN speculates:
I love the song Smiling Islands. I believe the analogy is excellent. I think what Robbie is saying is that these two people will seperate with respect for each other. Although they will still see each other, they will only smile and say hello from a distance like two islands that are in view of each other but never coming within any intimate, physical or pschological contact.